Sizing the prize: Using a bottom-up approach - Step 1

LinkedIn Twitter Facebook


Chris Jones

Author: Chris Jones, Independent Multichannel Retail Consultant




In the two previous articles (‘Sizing the prize: Using a top-down approach - Step 1’ and ‘Step 2’), we took a look at how to use high-level statistics and broad strategic perspectives to form a top-down estimate of potential eCommerce sales in a target country. It’s obviously important to do this to help build the business case for investing in a focused drive for sales there, for example by creating a localised site.


Estimation processes are often heavily dependent on a small number of key assumptions (such as the weighting-factors used in the suggested methodology), and so it’s always a good idea to have an alternative method to hand to corroborate, or challenge, your results. The most important factor in any such alternative is that is should use a completely different set of key assumptions if at all possible.


Given that we used a top-down approach previously, a bottom-up methodology is a nice contrast, which typically won’t duplicate key factors in the assumption process and which therefore should lead to a reasonably independent alternative estimate. Once you have both top-down and bottom-up estimates available together you can explore why they don’t meet in the middle (or be very suspicious if they do so first time through!). The outcome should be a much more robust business-case assumption that if you were to adopt either methodology alone.


The approach we’ll use here is once again two-step:


In step 1, we’ll estimate the expected visitors. In step 2 we’ll move on to estimate cart-sizes and conversion rates for these visitors.


Step 1 - estimating site visitors


For the purposes of this estimation, we’ll divide the traffic that arrives on a site into five rather broad types – direct; natural search; paid-for (e.g. SEM, or affiliate) directly driving visits; “effort”-driven (typically social media activities); retention / reactivation – and consider each in turn.


Well start with direct. You are probably already receiving visitors from your target country. Of course these visitors can be switched to a local site, if that is your plan. However your baseline assumption should be that there will be no incremental direct visitors simply in consequence of localising, unless you have statistics suggesting that there is pent-up interest in your brand. Direct traffic is almost always proportional to brand strength; if your marketing budget intends to build your brand locally, you can plan for some increase, but not otherwise (incidentally overseas visitors that do take the trouble to track down your UK site often convert exceptionally well – they really want to buy your stuff. You cannot assume that this will be true as you cast the net wider).


Next up is natural search traffic. If you localise / translate your site, you should expect to capture a good proportion of the local traffic for each keyword. However it takes time to get anywhere near as good at SEO as you are on home ground. A sensible planning assumption is that your keyword ranking will be two places lower in a foreign language, or one place lower in an English-speaking country, than you are used to at home, and that probably it will take 3-6 months even to reach this level.


The chart below (taken from The Multichannel Retail Handbook 2016 Edition) gives an indication of the consequences of this. If you are used to being ranked #2, but will now be ranked #4, then you’re only going to capture half the usual share of traffic. If you are enjoying the benefits of top ranking at home, then the drop-off will be unpleasant.


Click Through rates by Search Results


However this is of course only half the story. A very important point to remember, which it is surprisingly easy to overlook at the planning stage, is:


If there’s no traffic, you can’t capture it!


If the bulk of your home traffic is driven by searches for brand-terms (e.g. “PGTips”, “PGTips Tea Bags”, “PG Tips Tea” etc), and there’s zero volume for your brand in the target country, you might capture 100% of zero, whether via direct, natural or paid traffic! If, on the other hand, your home traffic is driven by generic terms (e.g. “English tea”), then you’ll be competing with already locally-established players.


These same principles are also true of paid traffic. In another article (Global SEM Costs Part 2), you can find a proposal for how to roughly estimate the likely traffic you can get for generic terms without undertaking a lengthy translation exercise first. For brand terms, the fastest method is to take a look at Google Trends, although the Keyword Planning tools will also do the trick (and is much easier to turn into a spreadsheet!).


Google Analytics Results


In the same article, you will also find a comparison of the cost of paid traffic in various different countries. In general, the US is more expensive and most other western countries are about 60-80% of the cost of the UK – more detail in Global SEM Costs Part 2. So you can expect to get slightly less / more bang for your buck depending where you are targeting.


What I’ve termed effort-driven traffic – for example as a consequence of activity on social media – is less brutally (and often depressingly) arithmetic. Language is obviously a big issue, and the overall story might be rather similar to that for direct traffic – you can move existing fans over, but attracting new ones depends on other marketing activities too. However social-media type activities have a secondary benefit of being marketing in the true sense. What you obviously can’t assume is an immediate leap to a level in the new country proportional to its population, even if you do decide to invest in local language, local thought-leaders or local celebrities; what you might be able to assume is that you can get there over time, perhaps using the same 10%:20%:40%;70%:100% growth rate over five years that we used in the top-down estimation processes.


Finally we have retention / reactivation, both directly by methods like Google Remarketing (which isn’t fully available in all countries – do check the rollout phasing if you’re considering somewhere relatively obscure) or tools like email campaigns, or the more indirect “second purchase” which is implicit in many of the figures above. The obvious point to make here is that until you have visitors, or buyers, there’s nobody to retain or reactivate. Your planning assumption for year 1 should probably be close to zero traffic from this source.


In each case, it’s possible to make a reasonable comparison with data that you already know - the traffic in your home country – and consider the factors that will make it less in a new one. The overall messages are:


  • be very cautious in your estimates in general
  • be very careful not to double count
  • expect to be considerably less effective in a new country, especially to begin with, even when using techniques you know well
  • finally, to repeat: if there’s no traffic, you can’t capture it. If you are dependent on a strong brand in the UK, and your brand is not strong in your target country, then brand-building has to come first


Once you’ve estimated the likely traffic you might be able to attract, we need to consider whether you will be more or less effective in converting it, which is the subject of the next article.


LinkedIn Twitter Facebook

Royal Mail Sponsor

Register today for unlimited article views, and unique insights

Register Now

Why international e-tailers should re-visit the top of the funnel

Why international e-tailers should re-visit the top of the funnel

The role of brand awareness is increasingly critical to international expansion and with various platforms offering better reach and targeting than ever before, why is it important for international retailers to revisit the top of the funnel to help create a more compelling picture?
Quality of delivery offer important to Dutch shoppers

Quality of delivery offer important to Dutch shoppers

Cross-border eCommerce in Belgium and the Netherlands is making big strides and with a population of 28 million people and combined GDP of €1.08trn and English spoken widely, it’s no wonder it offers an attractive market to international merchants looking to expand into new territories. But does the quality of delivery offered that important to Dutch shoppers?
How to maximise your chances of success in India

How to maximise your chances of success in India

eCommerce is growing at an unprecedented rate in India thanks to a number of factors and with the percentage of online retail sales growing rapidly, what do retailers need to consider in order to maximise their chances of success in India?
What do Russian consumers want when it comes to cross-border shopping?

What do Russian consumers want when it comes to cross-border shopping?

Russia is the 9th biggest country in the world with roughly 30 million online Russian shoppers in 2015 which only continue to grows in 2016. However, with cross-border shopping being the fastest-growing segment of the Russian eCommerce market, what do Russian consumers want when it comes to cross-border shopping?
The importance of understanding what it is to be Russian

The importance of understanding what it is to be Russian

Russia, in terms of internet penetration, did lag behind most other European countries but is rapidly playing catch up. Not surprisingly, eCommerce has increased alongside internet penetration with an estimated 148 million orders generated in 2015. But with so many unknowns surrounding entering the Russian market, what are the golden rules?
What should retailers know about Russian attitudes to parcel deliveries?

What should retailers know about Russian attitudes to parcel deliveries?

Russia offers a potentially attractive market for international merchants, however the market needs careful consideration in order to get it right. Things to take into account include the distinctly different Russian way of thinking, along with the legal rules and political context of the country. So what are the key things retailers need to know?
Retail Pricing in a post-Brexit world

Retail Pricing in a post-Brexit world

Since Brexit, a number of events have taken place which has meant the price of items has significantly dropped in the UK. But what are the affects of the UK leaving the European Union on retail pricing?
Australia extends tax to foreign eCommerce

Australia extends tax to foreign eCommerce

For a number of valid reasons, Australia is still a destination firmly in the minds of any business looking to expand into the APAC region. With an attractive foreign eCommerce tax law favoring companies coming into Australia, what are the big changes coming down the line in 2017?
Managing cross-border payments in a booming Chinese eCommerce market

Managing cross-border payments in a booming Chinese eCommerce market

Cross-border eCommerce sales in China are rocketing but with a challenging market for Western retailers to expand into, do retailers really understand the key to success when it comes to cross-border payments?
China - a trillion-dollar-sized pie?

China - a trillion-dollar-sized pie?

Not only is China the world’s largest and fastest growing eCommerce market, but online shopping continues to rise significantly with online spending estimated to reach over one trillion dollars by 2020. So is China currently at the forefront of your mind?

Contact Us

eCommerce Worldwide
2 Ching Court
49-53 Monmouth St

Tel: 0203 696 0980
2016© eCommerce Worldwide

Keep In Touch

powered by Affino

About eCommerce Worldwide

eCommerce Worldwide provides online retailers with all the information, and resources, they need to develop cross-border strategies for entering new markets around the world
Read More