Global SEM Costs Part 2

LinkedIn Twitter Facebook

 

Chris Jones

Author: Chris Jones, Independent Multichannel Retail Consultant

 

Comparing Countries?

 

In a previous article I took a look at the effectiveness of comparing SEM costs from one country to the next, as part of the budgeting/planning process of considering whether to localise your e-commerce offer for a particular new country.

 

In that article, I explored using global brand-names as a possible methodology for doing so, as a way of eliminating language bias from the comparisons. The results were fairly reasonable, but the suspicion remains that, even if language was eliminated as an issue, cultural bias – the relative popularity of brands around the globe – still skewed the results.

 

In this follow up article, I take a look at an alternative method, one that is probably closer to how most retailers might actually tackle the issue in reality, which uses generic terms instead of brand terms.

 

Methodology: using global online retailers

 

There are a small number of retailers whose proposition is, deliberately, very consistent across the multiple geographies in which they operate. IKEA is one such. However an exploration of their international sites, at least in languages I can read, reveals a surprising amount of difference in the website taxonomies. Moreover, I suspect that the majority of retailers considering taking their e-commerce international are not likely to be selling furniture.

 

A reasonable alternative is another Swedish retailer that’s gone global: H&M. A look at the “Ladies” section of their site suggests that it is very consistently structured across all the 61 countries in which they are operating. Moreover, even the non-transactional countries seem to have pretty much the same taxonomy. (There are evidently 2 slightly different releases of the site running globally):

 

H&M SEO Keywords

 

This suggests another methodology for comparing SEM costs, which in contrast to using branded terms, uses generic terms: simply take the second-level taxonomy from H&M’s site around the world and, once again, use the Google Keyword Planning tool to compare costs. This should have the advantage that not only has someone else pre-solved the translation issue for us, but the terms should be relatively free of cultural bias too – a shirt is consistently a shirt everywhere.

 

(Note that I have additionally separate terms such as “Jackets & Coats” into two separate terms “Jackets”, “Coats”; I wouldn’t like to swear in court to the precision with which I achieved this task in Japanese, although it was fairly simple in most other languages.)

Results

 

Before showing the graphs, I should note that of course there will still be some bias: coats are likely to be less popular in hot countries for example, and I have a sneaking suspicion that only the British wear socks. By once again weighting the averages according to the popularity of the search terms, I hope to have minimised this bias. There’s also a small secondary advantage from using a Swedish retailer: their original taxonomy will have been designed in Swedish, which removes the skew-to-English generally inherent this approach.

So what does it show?

 

H&M Ladieswear weighted average prices

 

I suspect the apparent cheapness of Japan, Korea and probably Russia reflect the fact the Google is not the dominant search engine in those countries. However in the case of Korea, especially, there is a suspicion that this may be compounded by H&M making a poor job of translation – the search volumes identified by Google are surprisingly low in a country where they do have at least a 9% share. (The H&M site is not transactional in Korea, so they maybe haven’t put too much effort into optimisation.) As an aside, retailers localising their sites might want to make use of the relative popularity of the translated terms they choose as a sanity check on the translations.

 

Elsewhere we see a macro-trend: from an SEM efficiency perspective, English language countries are much tougher than European countries. This might be another helpful factor when attempting to justify the costs of translation: not only will conversion rates probably improve, and SEO definitely improve, but it may be cheaper than expected to drive visitors directly via paid methods.

Comparison: branded vs generic

Comparing the approach from the previous article, focussing on international brands such as Nike, Samsung or Lego, with this one focussing on translated menu items such as Jackets, Trousers or Shirts, we see the following:

 

SEM Costs - branded vs generic SEO terms

 

Pleasingly the results are pretty consistent between the two methods. I’d conjecture that the major inconsistencies can be explained as follows:

 

Belgium and Italy: e-commerce is surprisingly immature compared to general use of the internet. Searches for branded terms are inherently more likely – and therefore expensive – as online research is more prevalent than online shopping. Note that the generic results for Belgium were based only on Dutch, which probably also affects the data (and possibly contributes to the opposite effect appearing for NL).

 

Korea, Russia and UAE: possible poor translation by H&M. In Russia there is also the likelihood that internet users are much more likely to be searching for international brands, which may well be the explanation for the UAE also.

Conclusions

The overall conclusions from these two studies (see also ‘Global SEM Costs’) suggest that:

  1. Comparing Google estimated traffic is a good way of validating your choice of menu taxonomy terms: is this really a word that the locals use?
  2. France is an anomaly. If anyone can suggest some reason why France seems to be surprisingly cheap for SEM in both these studies – it is, after all, a Google country – then it would be interesting to understand it further. (The results are in fact inexplicably inconsistent with my personal experience).
  3. There may be some interesting opportunities in less-developed countries to grab customers cheaply.
  4. There may also be opportunities in countries where Google has a moderate, but non-zero share, such as Japan, Korea or Russia.
  5. SEM marketing in English speaking countries is expensive!

 

LinkedIn Twitter Facebook

Royal Mail Sponsor

Register today for unlimited article views, and unique insights

Register Now

5 tips for breaking into online retail in France

5 tips for breaking into online retail in France

France boasts being the 5th largest eCommerce market in the world and with an expectation to exceed €80 billion turnover in 2017, for those looking to enter this thriving online market here are five tips that could help you to break into the French online retail space.
Interview with Melanie Smallwood, International Buying Director at Global Fashion Group

Interview with Melanie Smallwood, International Buying Director at Global Fashion Group

eCommerce Worldwide Cross-Border Summit 2017 - Ahead of our annual event on 24th May, we interview Melanie Smallwood, International Buying Director at Global Fashion Group, to learn from her experience and knowledge in cross-border trading around the world.
Interview with Gregor McMillan, Business Development, China at The Hut Group

Interview with Gregor McMillan, Business Development, China at The Hut Group

eCommerce Worldwide Cross-Border Summit 2017 - Ahead of our annual event on 24th May, we interview Gregor McMillan, Business Development, China at The Hut Group, to learn from his experience and knowledge in cross-border trading into China.
Interview with Michael Truluck, CEO at La Redoute

Interview with Michael Truluck, CEO at La Redoute

eCommerce Worldwide Cross-Border Summit 2017 - Ahead of our annual event on 24th May, we interview Michael Truluck, CEO at La Redoute, to learn from his experience and knowledge in cross-border trading.
The latest view on eCommerce in Germany

The latest view on eCommerce in Germany

There are many benefits to entering the German eCommerce market - it’s the 3rd largest online market in Europe and has a very high internet penetration rate, but what other staistics do you need to know before entering this lucrative country?
How to use colour in cross-border online retail

How to use colour in cross-border online retail

Did you know colour can be an important driver of eCommerce sales? Research suggests 85% of buyers make their purchasing decision based on colour so getting it wrong could be a fundamental disaster for any online business. So what is the right colour to use?
Interview with Richard Longhurst, Co-Founder and Director at Lovehoney

Interview with Richard Longhurst, Co-Founder and Director at Lovehoney

eCommerce Worldwide Cross-Border Summit 2017 - Ahead of our annual event on 24th May, we interview Richard Longhurst, Co-Founder and Director at Lovehoney, to learn from his experience and knowledge in cross-border trading.
Building an eCommerce fraud prevention strategy for Germany

Building an eCommerce fraud prevention strategy for Germany

Being the world’s fifth largest eCommerce market, Germany has become an exceptionally popular destination for online merchants looking to sell their goods and services. However, retailers should still be aware of the high levels of fraud to do with their number one payment method. Therefore, what do you need to know about building an eCommerce fraud prevention strategy for Germany?
Interview with Kai Li, Vice President of International at Revolve

Interview with Kai Li, Vice President of International at Revolve

eCommerce Worldwide Cross-Border Summit 2017 - Ahead of our annual event on 24th May, we interview Kai Li, Vice President of International at Revolve Clothing, to learn from his experience and knowledge in cross-border trading.
How does device usage differ in France, Germany, and the UK?

How does device usage differ in France, Germany, and the UK?

It is well known that the use of smartphones and tablets has grown rapidly but which device dominates the traffic and at what time of day across France, Germany and UK? And how does device usage differ between these Countries?

Contact Us

eCommerce Worldwide
2 Ching Court
49-53 Monmouth St
London
WC2H 9EY

Tel: 0203 696 0980
2016© eCommerce Worldwide

Keep In Touch

powered by Affino

About eCommerce Worldwide

eCommerce Worldwide provides online retailers with all the information, and resources, they need to develop cross-border strategies for entering new markets around the world
Read More